Journal May 30, 2013

This post is for all of you teachers out there. It was on my facebook today. Read it and see if it doesn’t upset you like it did me.



May. 28, 2013 8:03am 

  • 449
  • 12.4K
  • 38
  • 8
  • 209

Ellie Rubenstein resigns from teaching job in YouTube video

As parents in several states have stood up against standardized education such as Common Core and CSCOPE, one teacher in the Chicago area (Highland Park) has taken a similar (although not necessarily directly related) stand that is now going viral.

Last week, 15-year teaching veteran Ellie Rubenstein posted a 10-minute YouTube video where she decried the state of test-centric eduction after the district she was working in said it was going to be transferring her and several other teachers– a move she says came because those teachers were vocal about their issues and one she says the district has attributed to concerns over the school’s “poor climate.”

“This is a total kangaroo court, a retaliation against four teachers who are quite vocal in advocating for their children,” Rubenstein said in an interview last week. “We are at the forefront of speaking our minds and at the forefront of advocating for our students. We are all being falsely accused by the administration and some colleagues of doing things we have never done, and saying things we have never said.”

Frustrated and out of options, Rubenstein decided to resign instead of face the transfer — and she did it in a way that has garnered over 350,000 views.

Among her concerns that have now gone viral:

  • “I have experienced the depressing, gradual downfall and misdirection of education that has slowly eaten away at my love of teaching.”
  • “The emphasis in eduction has shifted from fostering academic and personal growth in both students and teachers, to demanding uniformity and conformity.”
  • “Raising students’ test scores on standardized tests is now the only goal, and in order to achieve it the creativity, flexibility and spontaneity … have been eliminated.”
  • “Everything I loved about teaching is extinct.”
  • “Curriculum is mandated. … The classroom teacher is no longer trusted or in control of what, when, or how she teaches.”
  • She says complaint forms and write-ups are being used as tools to target teachers and keep them as “yes men,” instead of being used to get rid of poor educators — and she even takes a shot at the union.

Watch the entire resignation — which includes plenty of more examples and quotes and even mentions “tracking” of students — below:

“I thought I would be a teacher for the rest of my life,” Rubenstein says as her voice begins to crack.

“I have to get out before my sense of self and self-worth is completely obliterated,” she adds later.

At a local school board meeting last Thursday, the issue came up and district Superintendent David Behlow denied Rubenstein’s claims while trying to answer to angry parents who say the “poor climate” reason is bogus:

Behlow said many of Rubenstein’s comments in the video “were inaccurate, misleading and, in many cases, factually wrong.”

“Our teachers are encouraged to be creative and innovative and to exercise their own craft and magic in classrooms every day,” Behlow said.

For more background, you can read the Chicago Sun-Times article here.

  • 449
  • 12.4K
  • 38
  • 8


Margaret Quiggle Driver My bachelor’s is in Bio/Chem from LHU. After my youngest started school, I seriously considered getting my teacher’s certification from Lycoming College, but I decided against it after learning about the ‘new’ teaching methods, ‘teaching to the test, restrictions, etc, it just didn’t seem worth it to me. Plus, I don’t agree with how the system works now. Over the years, I have collected school books from the late 19th and early 20th centuries. When my kids came home from school, as wel as during vacations and breaks, I had them work from those books, particularly in reading and mathematics.




America, WAKE UP!


Margaret Quiggle Driver likes a photo.


  • Like Page

    Yes it is!! JT
    Yes it is!! JT
    Unlike ·  · Share · 1,623441,275 · Tuesday at 6:16pm ·

    • You and 1,621 others like this.
    • Anthony Capezzali Cindy are you afraid to say what you mean? Intimidation by your government is not OK
      20 hours ago · Like · 1
    • Marcie Bauer It is truly frightening to watch the masses and the media sit by and allow this man to bury our country. And hardly a word is said against him!! It was going under after four years, and he talked them into another four years to finish the job…I guess by scaring them and appealing to their greed. How’s that Hope and Change working for you, now?
    • Bonnie Jean Hern American people, WAKE UP AND SEE THE HANDWRITING ON THE WALL!!
      Something else to read and consider how you feel afterwards.
      Judy Oates Beecham likes a photo.


      • Like Page

        How many Likes and Prayers for premature babies??? — withRosie Thurston and 44 others.
        How many Likes and Prayers for premature babies???

        Unlike ·  · Share · 883,95720,59727,301 · May 24 at 11:16pm ·

        • You and 883,956 others like this.
        • Bonnie Jean Hern To see the lengths that parents who want and love their children will go to when the babies are born much much too early, is simply amazing. And then you think about all of the innocent babies that were aborted because for whatever reason the parents didn’t want them, I just want to cry.
        • Tammy Wertz My great-aunt was born premature, much like this little one, in 1910. In those days, women had their babies at home. She weighed 2lbs and her skin was so thin, you could see right through it. She was so fragile, they carried her around on a pillow. During the day, she lay in a basket on the open oven door to keep her warm, & at night, she slept in a dresser drawer. The doctor said she wouldn’t survive the week. She died in 2007 at the age of 97. & she out-lived all of her siblings. Don’t ever doubt the power of prayer
          Like · Reply · 5,903 · 19 hours ago · Edited
          • 158 Replies
        • Stephanie Damron Yes i had one 20wks only 14oz 9in long. She had alot off prob first 2yrs of her life but now going to be 6 in july with NO MEDICAL HANDICAPS..!! God is sooo amazing.!!!!
          Like · Reply · 8,097 · 20 hours ago
          • 122 Replies